Dependably honest

We were doing a paper on the character quality of dependability.  One of the scenarios was, "What do you do if you know you missed second base in a baseball game but nobody else notices?"  I remarked that it seemed more like an honesty issue than a dependability one.  Sarah said, "No, it's dependability.  The players are depending on you to be honest."  Noah said, "I'm depending on the umpire to do his job."